top button
Flag Notify
    Connect to us
      Site Registration

Site Registration

Find 30 fake coins out of 99 coins with minimum amount of weighting?

0 votes
206 views

You are given 99 coins which consists of 30 fake ones. You also have a digital balance scale with perfect precision that shows how much difference between weighs you put on. For example, if you put 10 g on the left side and 20 g on the other side, it will show -10, otherwise +10.

You are asked to find a fake coin among given 99 coins:

  • You know that all genuine coins have the same weight but you do not know their weights.
  • You also know that every fake coin is heavier or lighter by 1 gram than any genuine coin.

So, what is the minimum amount of weighing which guarantees to find any fake coin you are looking for? (The fake coin you are going to find might be heavier or lighter, it does not matter, you just need to find any fake one.)

posted Jan 7, 2017 by anonymous

Share this puzzle
Facebook Share Button Twitter Share Button LinkedIn Share Button

1 Answer

0 votes

If the goal here is to just find a single fake coin then from the information given there are 99 - 30 = 69 original coins. So by seperating 70 coins from the rest we are assuring that atleast one fake coins enters the 70 coin pile.
Now we must weigh 2 coins at a time. Whenever there are imbalances the coins should be marked '+' if it's heavier '-' if it's lighter. Whenever the coins balance each other the coins are both original or fake which can be used to inspect + and - coins later on.

Now coming to determining the minimum steps required an extreme case of 40 original and 30 fake coin scenario can be helpful. Here 30 original coins could possibly be paired with 30 fake while weighing ( another worst case) giving us + and - coins, which leaves us with 30 weighs done. Now the remaining 5 pairs are going to balance with each other ( again a sample case) and here 35 weighs are done. Now weighing + coins one at a time with all the coins that balanced ( again one at a time ) will help decide which coin is fake. If all the balanced coins balanced with + coins then - is the fake coin else + is fake. But we have to make sure that all the balanced sets are original (and in case both + and - coins show imbalance). To do that 2 balanced pairs are taken. One of the coins of a pair is placed on one side of a pan and and a coin from another pair on the other. If it's balanced then both pairs are original if not then one of the 2 pairs have a fake set in it. So these pairs can be compared with tested original pairs to determine the fake
So the final tally of weighings is 43 weighs.

[ P.S: I could easily be wrong here as well LOL ! ]

answer Jan 8, 2017 by Tejas Naik



Similar Puzzles
0 votes

There are 10 bags full of coins out of which one bag is full of fake coins which we don’t know. But you do know that genuine coins weigh 01 gram, but fake weighs 1.1 grams. We have to identify that bag in minimum readings a digital weighing machine.

0 votes

In front of you, there are 9 coins. They all look absolutely identical, but one of the coins is fake. However, you know that the fake coin is lighter than the rest, and in front of you is a balance scale. What is the least number of weightings you can use to find the counterfeit coin?

0 votes

f I have less than $1 in coins, what is the largest amount of money I could have and not be able to give someone exactly 50p?

...