# Did I speak to Tina or Meena?

146 views

Tina & Meena are twins. One of them lies while the other is truthful. I asked one of them, “Does Tina lie?” “Yes”, was the answer.
Did I speak to Tina or Meena?

posted May 12, 2014

## 2 Solutions

+1 vote

If Tina lied , then the reply from Tina , would be no, the reply from Meena would be yes.
If Meena lied the reply from Meena would be yes and Tina would be No
So "yes" could be an answer only from Meena

solution May 12, 2014
+1 vote

if the person talks to meena and the proposition is true then teena says lie and meena says truth,if false then teena says truth and meena lies...
say:
p=meena says truth
q=teena says truth
if we take the condition that p says truth and q says falsethen (p or not q)and p==p;where meena is answer

solution May 15, 2014

Similar Puzzles

I have no voice, yet I speak to you;
I tell of all things in the world that people do.
I have leaves, but I am not a tree.
I have a spine and hinges, but I am not a man or a door; I have told you all, I cannot tell you more.

What am I?

I come via Latin from Greek,
Step in the direction of something big, so to speak.

The scholars know me very well,
Without me, they may fail.

I provide a helping hand to all,
and found sometimes on flowers so small.

Though stepping stone, I am always a minor,
But I always make my dependent finer.
who am I?

Hint :
Everyone come across this thing in middle/high school or in college, but most of us ignores it wholeheartedly