# Since there has been no breach of marriage law, how can you explain such a relationship?

73 views

Carl Jones introduced Roger Smith to his friend as his Uncle Roger. Roger Smith introduced Carl Jones to his friend as his Uncle Carl.
"If you are uncles to each other," queried one of the friends, "you must also be nephews to each other."
"That's correct," replied Carl.
Since there has been no breach of marriage law, how can you explain such a relationship?

posted Jul 9, 2015

## 1 Solution

Suppose a divorced or widowed woman A has a son C & woman B has a son D...
A marries D and B marries C and both couples have a son. A&D has a son named Carl Jones and B&C has a sone named Roger Smith.
Now, Carl Jones is step brother of C (being sons of A) and Roger Smith is step brother of D (being sons of B)... So, Carl Jones is uncle of Roger Smith being brother of his father C and Roger is uncle of Carl being brother of his father D and they both are nephews to each other too.

solution Dec 29, 2015 by anonymous

Similar Puzzles
+1 vote

There were two grandmothers and their two granddaughters.
There were two husbands and their two wives.
There were two fathers and their two daughters.
There were two mothers and their two sons.
There were two maidens and their two mothers.
There were two sisters and their two brothers.
Yet there are only six, who are buried here,
All are born legitimate and relationships clear.
How can this happen?