# Who won the race?

+1 vote
391 views

Four children had a race. At the end of the race

Robert: I didn't come in first or last
David: I didn't come in last
Melissa: I was first
Bailey: I was last

You know that one, and only one, of the children
didn't tell the truth.

Who won the race?

posted Oct 13, 2014

## 2 Solutions

Ans: David won the race
and Melissa didn't told the truth.

This question can be solved by taking different cases and goal is that given condition must be satisfied which is- only one children didn't told the truth.
In our case- Melissa didn't told the truth so he was not the first...
Bailey was last.
So Melissa occupied 2 or 3 position.
Robert is not first or last so he was also at position 2 or 3.
David didn't came last
and only 2 children can occupy 2 and 3 positions
It means David was the first

solution Dec 14, 2014

David came first
Mellisa was lying (If atall )

solution Mar 18, 2015

Similar Puzzles

Four athletes, Ann, Bea, Carol, and Dorothy went out one morning and ran a race. At the end of
the race, the following statements were made:
Ann: "I didn't come in first or last."
Bea: "I didn't come in last."
Carol: "I was first."
Dorothy: "I was last."
It is known that one, and one only, of the four athletes is lying.

Who won the race?

Jim, Catherine, Michele and Pete have participated in the school race.

The results are as follows;

Jim beats Catherine
Melanie beats Pete &
Pete beats Jim
Who came first in the race?

+1 vote

Sunil and Tapesh are two mad logicians and loves betting.
They placed 11 Candies at the table and designed a small betting game, in which both of them need to eat Candies turn by turn with the following rules:
Rule1: One need to eat at least one candy.
Rule2: One cannot eat more than 5 candies.

The one that eats last candy will loose.

Sunil won the toss and need to start.

How many candies must Sunil eat in order to make sure that he won the bet?

+1 vote

I say everything, I hear to others around. I'm not an animal, nor part of the human race. I will, immediately, repeat after you; But only if my tail is in place. What am I?